In many ways, my short story collection, “Dry Fly Gospel,” is confusing for people. It’s a book that is very hard to pin down—or, to put it into fishing terminology—tough to get into a net.
The stories are serious, but also ridiculous. There is parody, fantasy, mystery and adaptation within its pages. Some of the stories are told from a male perspective; some from a female point of view. Some stories are full from beginning to end of fishing exploits and descriptions; others may give a couple of lines or a paragraph to the actual hands-on subject of fly fishing.
Perhaps the biggest, problem, though, is finding an answer to this question: Is it a religious book, or a secular book? The answer is yes. While some of the stories are obviously religious in nature, and the structure of the collection is meant to parallel roughly that of the New Testament, with Gospels, Epistles and Revelations, the stories are also meant to stand as fiction of the sort practiced by the likes of Hemingway, MacLean and many others. Something for everybody. Layers of meaning. All that rot.
It would have been much easier for me to go completely one way or the other in describing and marketing. However, I felt the religious topics in several stories were too blatant to make the book a totally secular affair, and I didn’t feel the religion and fly fishing connection were strong enough to warrant calling it a “Christian,” or even a “religious,” book. After all, even though the title story, Dry Fly Gospel, was inspired by a quote from Norman MacLean’s “A River Ran Through It” (“He told us about Christ’s disciples being fishermen, and we were left to assume, as my brother and I did, that all first-class fishermen on the Sea of Galilee were fly-fishermen and that John, the favorite, was a dry-fly fisherman.”), trying to promote too heavily the connections between fly fishing and religion might turn off the secular market. Then I came across the work of Sam Snyder.
Dr. Samuel Snyder has a Library has a doctoral degree from the Religion and Nature program at the University of Florida. His dissertation was titled, “Casting for Conservation: Religion, Popular Culture, and the Politics of River Restoration.” Besides that, Snyder is a fellow this summer at the National Sporting Library, where he is studying the history of religion and environmental concerns in American angling.
In an article for the Summer 2008 issue of The American Fly Fisher, he begins an article based on his dissertation by saying: “It is no secret that fly fishers have historically taken their sport so seriously as to frequently elevate it to religious status. Fly fishers around the world frequently use terms such as religious, spiritual, sacred, divine, ritual, meditation, and conversion to describe their personal angling experiences. In doing so, fly fishers have no shortage of resources and traditions from which to build support for the religious designation of their sport.”
Snyder goes on to point out the various ways fly fishing takes on the status and importance of religious observance for many practitioners, and how that status informs and invigorates many fly fishers to take a proactive stance in the conservation and environmental movements. The premise is interesting, and his articles on the subject are well-written and painstakingly researched.
After reading some of Snyder’s work, I feel more confident about what I had thought was such an odd idea and collection. I feel like my stories could really resonate with a larger audience out there. I guess it’s up to me to figure out how to get “Dry Fly Gospel” to a larger audience. One key factor is word of mouth. If you’ve read my book and found it not horrible, perhaps you will tell your friends about it. Even if you haven’t read it, if you have friends who fly fish and/or read tell them about the book.
If you have the chance, look up some Snyder’s work online. You can find him, and copies of his articles, here: http://sites.google.com/site/samueldsnyder/